Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Prisons & Jails – Constitutional – Eighth Amendment – Jury Instructions – Intentional Actions

By: Teresa Bruno, Opinions Editor//December 15, 2017

Prisons & Jails – Constitutional – Eighth Amendment – Jury Instructions – Intentional Actions

By: Teresa Bruno, Opinions Editor//December 15, 2017

Anderson v. Kingsley (Lawyers Weekly No. 001-221-17, 14 pp.) (Paul Niemeyer, J.) 16-6957; Dec. 14, 2017; USDC at Newport News, Va. (Douglas Miller, USMJ) 4th Cir.

Holding: In this case involving a prisoner who was attacked and injured by another inmate, the district court instructed the jury, “Deliberate indifference is established only if the defendants . . . had actual knowledge of a substantial risk that Anderson would be injured . . . and if the defendants recklessly disregarded that risk by intentionally refusing or failing to take reasonable measures to deal with the risk.” “Intentionally” was properly used as a modifier for “refusing or failing”; deliberate indifference is the intentional taking of a risk that the defendant knows might cause harm while lacking any intent to cause such harm.

We affirm the judgment for defendants.

Business Law

See all Business Law News

Commentary

See all Commentary

Polls

How Is My Site?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...