After a jury determined the merger of two manufacturers in the American doorskin market violated the Clayton Antitrust Act, the remedy included unwinding the merger and ordering the sale of the acquired company. Background JELD-WEN Inc. acquired a competitor, CMI, ...
Read More »Antitrust Concrete – Price Fixing & Market Allocation – Civil Practice
Plaintiffs allege that defendants, who produce ready-mix concrete, engaged in secret communications, price fixing, and the dividing up of markets in South Carolina and Georgia. Plaintiffs’ allegations are sufficient to state a restraint-of-trade claim under § 1 of the Sherman ...
Read More »Antitrust – State Action Immunity – Public Utilities – Santee Cooper – Supra-competitive Prices
Century Aluminum of South Carolina, Inc. v. South Carolina Public Service Authority (Lawyers Weekly No. 002-171-17, 20 pp.) (Richard Mark Gergel, J.) 2:17-cv-00274; D.S.C. Holding: Where the defendant-electric utility has been granted a monopoly in a clear articulation of state ...
Tagged with: Public Utilities
Read More »Antitrust – Hospital Contracts – Nurse Staffing – Traveling & Temporary Nurses
Advance Nursing Corp. v. South Carolina Hospital Association (Lawyers Weekly No. 002-209-16, 13 pp.) (Mary Geiger Lewis, J.) 6:16-cv-00160; D.S.C. Holding: Plaintiff has stated an antitrust claim by alleging that defendants have conspired to control exclusively the traveling and temporary ...
Tagged with: Nurse
Read More »Antitrust – Panel Splits on Twombly Standard for Antitrust Claim
SD3 LLC v. Black & Decker U.S. Inc. (Lawyers Weekly No. 001-164-15, 98 pp.) (Agee, J.) No. 14-1746, Oct. 29, 2015; USDC at Alexandria, Va. (Cacheris, J.) 4th Cir. Holding: Plaintiff table-saw manufacturer states an antitrust claim by alleging defendant ...
Tagged with: Antitrust
Read More »Antitrust – Saw Company Group Boycott Claim Survives
SD 3LLC v. Black & Decker (U.S.) Inc. (Lawyers Weekly No. 001-155-15, 98 pp.) (Agee, J.) No. 14-1746, Sept. 15, 2015; USDC at Alexandria, Va. (Hilton, S.J.); 4th Cir. Holding: Plaintiff table-saw manufacturer states an antitrust claim by alleging defendant ...
Tagged with: Antitrust
Read More »Antitrust -Dental Board Action Violates Antitrust Law
N.C. State Board of Dental Examiners v. Federal Trade Comm’n A state agency that regulates the practice of dentistry cannot overturn a Federal Trade Commission decision that the agency’s efforts to shut down teeth-whitening services performed by non-dentists constituted unfair competition that violated federal antitrust law; the 4th Circuit rejects the state dentistry board’s petition for review of the FTC order.
Read More »Antitrust – Attempted Monopolization Claim – Insufficient Allegations – Relevant Market – Dangerous Probability of Success – Home Builders
Downeast Builders & Realty, Inc. v. Essex Homes Southeast, Inc. In its attempted monopolization counterclaim, defendant fails to allege what “identified subclass or submarket of new houses” or what “particularized price point” plaintiff is attempting to monopolize. Furthermore, defendant fails to allege the geographic market it claims plaintiff is attempting to monopolize.
Tagged with: Antitrust
Read More »Antitrust – Real Property – Multiple Listing Services – Anti-Competitive Bylaws – Putative Class Actions
Robertson v. Sea Pines Real Estate Companies Inc. The 4th Circuit says plaintiff buyers of real estate brokerage services in South Carolina have stated an antitrust claim under the Sherman Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1, with allegations that defendant brokerages that serve as board members of the local multiple listing service conspired to unfairly restrain market competition.
Tagged with: Antitrust Real Property
Read More »Antitrust – Civil Practice – Counterclaim Allegations – Geographic Market – Body Armor Fibers
E.I. DuPont de Nemours & Co. v. Kolon Industries Inc. (Lawyers Weekly No. 001-052-11, 29 pp.) (Wynn, J.) No. 10-1103, March 11, 2011; USDC at Richmond, Va. (Payne, J.) 4th Cir. Click here for the full text of the opinion. ...
Tagged with: Antitrust Civil Practice
Read More »