After the plaintiff-Wife had filed for divorce, she reviewed and agreed to a contract for the sale of the retiring defendant-Husband’s dental practice; the contract specified that $424,140 of the purchase price was for goodwill. Nevertheless, no evidence supports the ...
Read More »Domestic Relations – Parent & Child – Visitation – Hearsay – Medical Diagnosis – Mental Health Professional
The hearsay exception in Rule 803(4), SCRE, for statements made for the purpose of medical diagnosis or treatment may be subject to overextension; however, the exception can be reined in by trial court’s application of the “reasonably pertinent” requirement and ...
Read More »Domestic Relations – Divorce – Subject Matter Jurisdiction – N.C. Residents
Although the plaintiff-Husband presented some evidence that he intended his parents’ South Carolina home to be his residence, Husband returned to the parties’ North Carolina residence whenever his military service and airline employment allowed, and he also became involved in ...
Read More »Domestic Relations – Parent & Child – Custody Modification – School Performance
The parties’ younger daughter’s grades declined for some of the time she was in the defendant-Mother’s custody; however, her reading scores began to greatly improve approximately two weeks before the hearing in this matter. Further, the parties’ elder daughter was ...
Read More »Domestic Relations – Parent & Child – Emancipation – Equitable Distribution – Classification
Where the parties’ 18-year-old son had dropped out of high school and had been working full-time for one or two years, and where he had previously attended GED classes but stopped without receiving his GED, the fact that the son ...
Read More »Domestic Relations – Parent & Child – TPR & Adoption – Maternal Grandfather – Birth Certificate – Permanency
In considering the best interest of the minor child (Child) in this case, the family court appeared to give undue weight to the fact that, as a result of terminating the respondent-Father’s parental rights and allowing the petitioner-Grandfather to adopt ...
Read More »Domestic Relations – Alimony – Modification – Subject Matter Jurisdiction – Reasonable Time Requirement
The parties’ 2003 divorce decree said the alimony awarded to the defendant-Wife would be “non-modifiable and will cease only at the death of [Wife] or [the plaintiff-Husband] or the remarriage of [Wife].” Although this decree did not expressly deny the ...
Read More »Domestic Relations – Property Settlement – Civil Contempt – Advice of Counsel – Alimony – Attorney’s Fees
In the parties’ property settlement, the defendant-husband agreed to pay the plaintiff-wife up to $50,000 per year from payments he received “from patents, trademarks, and licensing agreements.” This provision was broad enough to encompass the quarterly payments defendant received from ...
Read More »Domestic Relations – Common-Law Marriage – Same-Sex Couple – Pre-Obergefell Separation
Obergefell v. Hodges, 576 U.S. 644 (2015), requires that we treat S.C. Code Ann. § 20-1-15, which prohibited same-sex marriage, as though the statute never existed. We vacate our Court of Appeals’ ruling that § 20-1-15 constituted a basis for ...
Read More »Domestic Relations – Termination of Parental Rights – Willful Failure to Visit Child – Sufficiency of Evidence
Parent willfully failed to visit with child where parent only attended two of 24 visitation dates and exercised phone call rights about half of the time, and refused family offers to move her closer to the child. We reverse the ...
Read More »