Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Opinion Digests

Feb 5, 2024

Civil Practice – Interlocutory Order – Consolidated Lawsuits – Leave to Intervene – Civil Conspiracy – Claim Preclusion

Circuit court erred in failing to analyze the issue and explain its decision related to whether a company should be allowed to intervene. We affirmed in part, reversed in part, […]

Feb 5, 2024

Civil Practice – Motion to Intervene – Prescriptive Easement – Fee Simple Title Claim – Rule 24 of the South Carolina Rules of Civil Procedure

The circuit court erred in denying appellant’s motion to intervene. We reversed the order denying appellant’s motion to intervene. DeBordieu Colony Community Association, Inc. is a private coastal community in […]

Feb 5, 2024

Real Property – Conservation Easement – Express Easement – Right to Access Parcel – Language in the Deed

The circuit court erred in interpreting section 4.3 of the Conservation Easement to give respondent an express easement over appellant’s Parcel to access respondent’s Parcel. We reversed the circuit court’s […]

Feb 5, 2024

Criminal Practice – Abuse of Discretion – Batson Analysis – Unrelated Prior Bad Act – Challenges to Strike Jurors

The circuit court did not abuse its discretion in failing to conduct the third step of the Batson analysis when considering the State’s explanations for using four of its five […]

Feb 5, 2024

Constitutional – Condemnation Proceedings – Statutory Limit – Leasehold Interest – Reestablishment Expenses – Just Compensation

The $50,000 statutory limit on reimbursement of reestablishment expenses in condemnation proceedings set forth in S.C. Code Ann. section 28-11-30(4) (Supp. 2023) is constitutional. We affirmed the circuit court. Appellant […]

Feb 5, 2024

Criminal Practice – Mistrial – Double Jeopardy – Admission of Photographs – Evidence – Admission of Text and Facebook Messages

The trial court exercised sound discretion in declaring a mistrial in defendant’s first trial, after conscientiously considering alternatives to the drastic remedy of declaring a mistrial. We affirmed the decision […]

Feb 5, 2024

Constitutional – Wrongful Termination – Defamation – Public Official – Limited Public Figure – Damages Award

Although petitioner was a public employee and enjoyed media attention akin to that of many sports figures, that does not transform him into a public official. We reversed the decision […]

Feb 5, 2024

Civil Practice – Breach of Contract – Res Judicata – Fraud – Fraudulent Concealment – Statute of Limitations – Survival Statute

Although Petitioner’s claim for breach of contract accompanied by fraudulent act survived Mrs. Hughes’ death, the claim is barred by res judicata. Petitioner’s causes of action for fraud and fraudulent […]

Feb 5, 2024

Criminal Practice – Jury Instruction – Definition of Malice – Without Just Cause or Excuse – The Hand of One Is the Hand of All – Burden of Proof

Because the trial court repeatedly instructed the jury on the State’s burden of proof, the phrase “intentional doing of a wrongful act without just cause or excuse” did not shift […]

Feb 5, 2024

Criminal Practice – Supervised Release – Oral Pronouncement – United States v. Rogers – Reporting Condition – Presentence Reports 

The written judgment’s inclusion of the reporting condition dispelled any ambiguity in the district court’s oral pronouncement.  Finding no error, we affirmed the judgment of the district court.  Quinn Hakeem […]

Feb 5, 2024

Criminal Practice Sentencing Guidelines – Downward Variance – Mitigation Argument – Court’s Discretion

The district court acted within its discretion in declining to vary defendant’s sentence downward.  We affirmed the district court’s judgment.  Ricky Dewayne Johnson pleaded guilty to assaulting a federal officer […]

Feb 5, 2024

Civil Practice – Pro Se – Family and Medical Leave Act – De Novo – Magistrate Judge – Statute of Limitations – Equitable Tolling 

As plaintiff’s objections satisfied the low bar of alerting the district court of the grounds on which he objected, the district court was required to review plaintiff’s objections de novo.  […]


Business Law

See all Business Law News

Commentary

See all Commentary

Polls

How Is My Site?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...